Paterson students got a lesson in the pitfalls of virtual learning this week when their online classes were interrupted by obscenities, pornography and threats against teachers.
But the city schools aren’t alone in dealing with electronic intrusions in the age of virtual learning. Similar incidents have been reported in districts across the country, from California, Miami and Ohio to Lumberton in Burlington County, which was bombarded with pornographic images and racist language during Zoom conferences in April.
Problems with online security and privacy are expected to grow with the majority of New Jersey schools shifting to full or part-time virtual learning because of the coronavirus pandemic, experts warn.
“Zoom bombing, cyberbullying, phishing – you name it. It has increased astronomically. Everybody needs to be really mindful about security right now,” said Kutub Thakur, an assistant professor and director of the Cyber Defense & Security Program at New Jersey City University.
“Because everything is online, hackers are more active. They target school systems and students who are young and they don’t really have any boundaries.”
In the spring, disruptions by intruders who shared hate-filled and pornographic content became so common that a new term was coined for the cyber-invasions: “Zoom bombing,” named for the popular videoconferencing platform. Zoom and other technology companies responded by unveiling security updates including encryption and new privacy controls.
In Paterson, this week’s intrusions came on Google Meet, another platform used widely by schools. At least 20 of the city’s roughly 50 schools were affected by the onslaught of inappropriate content, according to educators.
On Friday, the school district identified between five and 10 Paterson students who officials say may have been responsible. Officials said the culprits apparently got access to classes they were not enrolled in because students shared links and codes for the Google Meet sessions.
“If you have a public meeting where a password and link can be shared, that can cause problems,” said Jaideep Vaidya, director of the Rutgers Institute for Data Science, Learning, and Analytics. “People can log in from different accounts. They can share it with friends who are not even in school.”
ONLINE LEARNING: Edgewater school called police after sixth-grader had Nerf gun during Zoom class
DIGITAL DIVIDE: School has started, and NJ doesn’t know how many kids are caught in digital divide
The most important step, he said, was for schools to continuously update software applications and use security features that control when people get admitted, who gets admitted, and what they are allowed to do.
Schools can make meetings private, only open them to invited participants and ask students to log in with a unique ID and password. The meeting host can also use a “waiting room” where they admit students individually into an online class.
Some apps allow the host to block the transferring of files, mute microphones and restrict people from showing their screens.
Given the sheer number of people online, more problems can be expected. And it’s not just salacious content that’s a concern.
Vulnerabilities of online learning
Schools are vulnerable to phishing, where scammers use fraudulent emails to access personal information or install malware. That can lead to ransomware attempts, when scammers get access to a system and block a school from accessing data and files until a ransom is paid.
Ransomware attacks were reported in Livingston and in Cherry Hill last fall, while Somerset Hills was hit last week. For criminals, the schemes may look even more attractive now, Vaidya said, given how dependent schools and other institutions are on virtual learning. That could drive up ransom demands or make districts more likely to pay promptly, he said.
Thakur, of New Jersey City University, said schools must ensure anti-virus software and firewalls are up to date and that security devices are checked on a regular basis. Schools also should back up all information and files in case of a ransomware attack.
Cybersecurity problems result from human action, so schools must educate staff, students and parents to prevent them, Thakur stressed.
“Invest in online security education and how you protect yourself,” he said. “In every class, there should be some kind of security awareness training and some sort of security guidelines.”
Another tip: Schools should provide a disclaimer or warning that information about online classes and activity is restricted and cannot be shared outside invited participants.
In Paterson, officials are trying to get that message across by disciplining the suspects who disrupted learning in nearly half the city’s schools.
Paterson Superintendent Eileen Shafer said the district is in the process of confirming the students’ roles in the disruptions and may impose suspensions by Monday.
Shafer also said the Passaic County Prosecutor’s Office would be notified about students who showed pornographic images in the virtual classes and the Paterson Police Department alerted about those who made threats.
“There’s zero tolerance for this,” Shafer said in an interview. “We wouldn’t tolerate it in a classroom in a physical building and we won’t tolerate it online.”
Joe Malinconico contributed to this report.
Hannan Adely is an education and diversity reporter for NorthJersey.com. To get unlimited access to the latest news, please subscribe or activate your digital account today.
Email: email@example.com Twitter: @adelyreporter