Former deputy chief health officer Dr Nick Coatsworth has taken a swipe at draconian Covid rules that forced schools to close to stop the spread of Covid-19.
Dr Coatsworth took to Twitter this week, amplifying a scathing thread by Professor Francois Balloux, who was critical about extended school closures, that he blamed politicians, journalists and so-called ‘experts’ for.
The director of the UCL Genetics Institute wrote: ‘At the risk of annoying everyone, extended school closures happened because:
- Some in society believed it was a price worth paying
- Some journalists believed this is what their audience wanted to hear
- Some politicians believed it was popular
- Some ‘experts’ pushed for it.’
Another Twitter user added a fifth reason to the list.
‘I’d add: ‘5. Kids were seen as nothing else than vectors of disease,’ they said, with Dr Coatsworth ‘liking’ the message.
Dr Coatsworth (pictured in 2020) has chimed in to a Twitter thread initiated by Professor Francois Balloux, who gave four reasons for extended school closures in the UK
Another Twitter user added a fifth stakeholder to the professor’s list tweeting: I’d add: ‘5. Kids were seen as nothing else than vectors of disease’ – which Dr Coatsworth later liked
The infectious disease physician has been publicly critical of other experts who called for school students to remain home and be subject to strict mask rules.
During a surge in Omicron cases in January, he criticised doctors who said students should remain home as the first weeks of the school year approached.
Professor Kerryn Phelps, a doctor and former Deputy Lord Mayor of Sydney, posted a video on her social media warning parents not to send their kids to school.
‘As a doctor, this really disturbs me,’ she said after it was announced in-person classes in NSW would resume in January. ‘Sending children back to the classroom in the peak of a pandemic makes absolutely no sense.’
‘Ignore this individual,’ Dr Coatsworth replied in a blunt dismissal of her position.
The outspoken physician said the priority must be keeping schools open and not further stunting the educational growth of Australia’s children.
‘The starting point is keeping children at school and starting the term as plan. All subsequent actions flow from that,’ he said earlier this year.
‘Hybrid learning or remote learning needs to be resisted by Australian parents. There is no justification for it.’
‘The starting point is keeping children at school and starting the term as plan. All subsequent actions flow from that,’ Dr Coatsworth said earlier this year
Dr Coatsworth has been publicly critical of other experts who called for students to remain home and be subject to strict mask rules (pictured, students at Tweed Heads Public School)
Dr Coatsworth has hit out at rules requiring primary school students to wear masks in Victorian classrooms, previously explaining disease was mild in these age groups.
He said the virus spread ‘far more readily’ in adults and that the data did not prove masks were particularly effective at protecting children under 11 from Covid.
Earlier this month, the doctor took to Twitter to slam those continuing to demand more Covid rules and said some restrictions had done more bad than good.
‘We locked down our society, stopped children attending school, closed playgrounds, fined the least fortunate, separated families, created a mental illness, all in the name of protecting our most vulnerable, yet for some it will never be enough. When will the moralising stop?’ Dr Coatsworth wrote.
A UNESCO map showing how long schools were closed in certain countries during the pandemic states Australian schools were closed for 44 weeks.
A UNESCO map (pictured) showing how long schools were closed in countries during the pandemic states Australian schools were closed for 44 weeks
Earlier this month, Dr Coatsworth took to Twitter to slam those continuing to demand more Covid rules and said some restrictions had done more bad than good
The map showed students in New Zealand were kept at home for 24 weeks, while in the United States, schools were closed for 71 weeks and 51 weeks in Canada.
UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced in March of 2020 that schools would be closed indefinitely, with students returning in September of 2021.
Students in NSW returned to face-to-face learning in late October of 2021 after almost four months of homeschooling and online learning.
More than 150,000 students in kindergarten, years 1 and 12, who returned a week early were reunited with other grades a week later.
In Victoria, Year 12 students returned to school full-time on October 6, with Prep students invited back to classrooms on October 18.
All other years joined them the following week on October 26 in a staggered approach to the return to schools adopted by both of the southern states.
Dr Coatsworth was appointed one of three new deputy chief medical officers under Dr Brendan Murphy in March 2020 during the early days of the pandemic
In a lengthy interview with Daily Mail Australia earlier this year, Dr Coatswroth described what has worked best in the nation’s response to the virus, what could have been done better and where we are heading.
He also slammed the ‘loud voices’ he says are still scaring Australians who should by now be learning to live with Covid.
Coatsworth maintains restrictions should be removed as soon as they are not demonstrably necessary and will continue speaking out when an issue such as forcing children to wear masks at schools bothers him.
‘My preference was always to look at the benefits and consequences of whatever restriction was brought in,’ he says.
‘I’ve thought in general that we were too slow to realise the negative consequences of most of the restrictions.’
Unlike some of the fearmongers he has railed against, the Sydney-born, Perth-raised father-of-three is an optimist. ‘I think we’re in a good spot in the pandemic compared to other nations,’ Coatsworth says
Some restrictions including curfews, particularly those enforced in Victoria, served no useful purpose. ‘Taping up the playgrounds was just bizarre,’ Coatsworth says. A playground is pictured taped-off at Flagstaff in Melbourne
At heart, unlike some of the fearmongers he has railed against, the Sydney-born, Perth-raised doctor and father-of-three is an optimist.
‘I think we’re in a good spot in the pandemic compared to other nations,’ he says.
‘It’s difficult for people to see that because the Omicron BA.1 and BA.2 variants have actually caused a lot of disruption, but we’ve got short memories, I think.’
Case numbers might be high but the fact intensive care units were coping was more significant.
Coatsworth says the best thing Australia has done in its fight against Covid is getting the vaccination rate to 95 per cent. ‘That’s an extraordinary number,’ he says. Wearing masks was important, ‘when we didn’t know much about the virus’
‘At the really pointy end, which I think is what we always have to bring it back to with the pandemic, is how much actual morbidity and mortality is this disease causing?’ he says.
‘It’s really quite small compared to the number of cases that there are in the community.’
Coatsworth notes almost 95 per cent of the population are now double-vaccinated and an ‘extraordinary number’ of people have infection-induced immunity.
‘I think that happening all at the same time will probably actually lead to a really big drop off in the cases,’ he says. ‘That’s the most likely thing.
‘You’ll get these little spikes of cases but the trend over time will be downwards towards eventually just low levels of circulating cases in the community.’
Coatsworth was appointed one of three new deputy chief medical officers under Dr Brendan Murphy in March 2020 during the early days of the pandemic.
The consultant physician in infectious disease and respiratory medicine was seconded from Canberra Hospital where he was clinical director of medical services.
‘People often wonder where I got the job from and it was partly being in Canberra – I knew all the players around the table,’ he says.
Coatsworth had previously volunteered with Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders) in Congo-Brazzaville, Chad and the Darfur region of Sudan.
He had also served as executive director of the National Critical Care and Trauma Response Centre in Darwin and led an Australian Medical Assistance Team to The Philippines in the wake of Typhoon Haiyan in 2013.
Just as significantly, Coatsworth had recent experience as a frontline clinical physician.
It also helped that he knew Professor Paul Kelly, who later replaced Murphy as chief medical officer, through the Trauma Response Centre.
Coatsworth studied medicine at the University of Western Australia where he met his future wife Rebecca Pearson, now a lung transplant physician, while dissecting foetal frogs. ‘It’s not the most romantic,’ he says.
Dr Coatsworth has long called for Covid restrictions to be removed when they stop working
The young doctor did his internship at Royal Perth Hospital then returned to Sydney where he worked at Royal North Shore Hospital before heading to Darwin.
Coatsworth and Pearson got together about seven years after they met and moved to Canberra when their two daughters and one son were aged one, five and three respectively. [They are turning seven, nine and 11 this year].
The first major government response to Covid was to shut international borders, which Coatsworth says bought valuable time to plan for the coming pandemic.
‘I was confident that we were doing our best but I certainly wasn’t confident about what would happen,’ he says.
Early priorities were securing personal protective equipment, ensuring intensive care bed capacity, and procuring and making ventilators.
‘It was all pretty united in the first six months,’ Coatsworth says. ‘I think national cabinet was working, the states and territories were doing things in a broadly consistent way.
‘And then when it started to fracture and different states started doing different things it started getting quite confusing.’
Coatsworth’s initial contract was for three months, later extended to six months, but he stayed on as a part-time adviser for another year.
He became a familiar face to most Australians from press conferences, television interviews and advertising campaigns but still thinks there was a lack of communication about where Covid was headed.
Coatsworth says it should have been made clearer that cases would eventually rise and there would be significant numbers of deaths but the health system could deliver care to those who needed it.
‘That was the message that we needed to shift to in early 2021, to kind of prepare people,’ he says.
‘But unfortunately there was always a very loud group that thought Covid should be eliminated at all costs and I think that did hold us back a bit.’
The ‘inevitable’ happened when the Delta strain hit.
Coatsworth is scathing of those who discouraged the take up of the AstraZeneca vaccine when it was linked to a tiny proportion of complications.
‘When the Delta wave came through it had the biggest impact on the people who had been eligible for AstraZeneca but had chosen not to get it,’ he says.
‘There were lives lost because of that anti AstraZeneca message. No question about it.’
Coatsworth says once the Pfizer vaccine became available residents of New South Wales and Victoria began getting the jab at an extraordinary rate.
‘I still think that’s the case that no other jurisdiction in the world did it as quickly.’
Coatsworth’s philosophy is that no policy was necessarily wrong at the start and that most measures were worth trying.
Coatsworth’s views are at odds with some more risk-averse commentators such as the ABC’s Dr Norman Swan (above) and former Australian Medical Association president Kerryn Phelps who favour restrictions
‘Most of us were pretty convinced that we needed the restrictions at the start,’ he says. ‘All the measures that we took were reasonable.
‘But because they represented an infringement on human rights they needed almost a weekly reconsideration.’
Coatsworth says the ‘default position’ was to bring in restrictions first and worry later about civil liberties, when the reverse should have happened.
Some restrictions including curfews, particularly those enforced in Victoria, served no useful purpose. ‘Taping up the playgrounds was just bizarre,’ Coatsworth says.
‘The idea that being outdoors was ever any risk to anybody was an example of how we went too far with our restrictions.’
Coatsworth says vaccine mandates were ‘very important early on’ to drive uptake but have passed their usefulness.
‘There’s very few people who are likely to change their minds now because of the mandates,’ he says.
Wearing masks was also important, ‘when we didn’t know much about the virus and may still be important if we have a more lethal variant.’
Lockdowns, because of their mental health consequences, ‘probably caused more harm than good’, Coatsworth says.
He also believes working from home now serves no purpose from a public health perspective.
‘I think there’s stuff to be said about work-life balance, giving people the opportunity to have days at home,’ he says.
‘But I think for the people who are concerned about coming back to work we just need to reassure them.’
Internal border closures should have had an exemption process that allowed people with good reasons to travel the opportunity to do so.
‘It’s not enough to stand in front of a press conference and say “these decisions are heartbreaking” when you’re stopping someone from seeing a loved pass away,’ Coatsworth says.
Coatsworth became a familiar face to most Australians from press conferences, television interviews and advertising campaigns but still thinks there was a lack of communication about where Covid was headed
‘I find it hard to describe those decisions in polite terms. I mean, we’re bloody Australians.’
Closing the nation’s borders was the right thing to do at the time but caused the same unnecessary hardships as shutting off states.
‘As an Australian citizen overseas, what on earth does citizenship mean if you can’t get home?’ Coatsworth says. ‘I think the right decision at the start but it set us off on a path that left us closed for far too long.’
Coatsworth agrees with vaccinating children aged five to 12 but does not think there will be much difference in disease severity in a vaccinated person and an unvaccinated child.
‘I have no problem that our child vaccination rates are sitting between 55 and 60 per cent,’ he says. ‘I don’t think that’s a major public health issue.’
Coatsworth reckons a fourth dose of vaccine is right for those with compromised immunity, and is probably worthwhile for those over 65.
‘For people under 65 unless they’ve got some pretty severe condition I reckon three doses is fine,’ he says.
Closing the nation’s borders was the right thing to do at the time but caused the same unnecessary hardships as shutting off states. Returning international travellers are pictured at Perth Airport in March this year
Coatsworth’s views are at odds with some more risk-averse commentators such as the ABC’s Dr Norman Swan and former Australian Medical Association president Kerryn Phelps who favour restrictions.
‘The problem is that group is loud and it’s influential,’ he says. ‘It’s a bit exhausting really.
‘I thought it’d be all done and dusted by now – not the pandemic – but this bloody argument.
‘It’s bad for the punters as well. No one wants to see duelling experts, but then you have a choice. Do you shut up and let them run the narrative?’
The emergence of an unexpected Covid variant which was highly transmissible and lethal across age groups would be the worst future scenario but was ‘very unlikely’, Coatsworth says.
He does not like to use the terms winning or losing when it comes to Covid-19.
‘Whilst I wouldn’t say winning or losing I would say we’ve put ourselves in a better position that most other nations,’ he says. ‘That’s how you’ve got to see it.
‘It’s a pandemic. We were never going to get through this with no deaths, no work force shortages, no supply chain disruptions. That’s just magical thinking.’
Coatsworth says Australians should ‘100 per cent’ be proud of how they have managed Covid-19.
‘It was a joint effort between government, health care workers and the community. What it actually proves is Australia is not as polarised as everybody thinks it is.’
After his secondment to the Department of Health ended Coatsworth went back to Canberra Hospital as the executive director of clinical services.
He is now completing a PhD on health in foreign policy at Australian National University where he also lectures, and offering the occasional Covid commentary.
‘I’m trying to do it less and less,’ he says. ‘I’m more and more conscious that I should be doing less and less. I’m not in government. I don’t hold an official position.’
But it is hard to say nothing when someone with a loud voice says something with which he strongly disagrees.
‘I suppose the best thing is to ignore them and just try to run a middle narrative, that’s probably the best thing to do,’ Coatsworth says.
‘Sometimes my personality gets in the way. I get a bit fed up and have a crack.
‘The one thing I just can’t sort of let go of is the kids in masks thing. That’s probably the only thing I’m going to stay very vocal about. I’m so convinced that that’s the wrong policy.’